Science

Density: Why a Ton of Feathers Takes a Truck

Density: Why a Ton of Feathers Takes a Truck

Which weighs more, a ton of iron or a ton of feathers? A ton, obviously, is a ton. The riddle only feels like a trick because our eyes judge by size, and size is exactly where the two loads part company. The property that separates them is density: how much mass is packed into each unit of volume. Run the numbers and the feathers do not need a bigger scale. They need a truck.

Mass packed into space

Density is mass divided by volume, and water sets the everyday benchmark at 1.00 grams per cubic centimetre. Iron packs in far more: about 7.87 grams per cubic centimetre, nearly eight times water. Cork goes the other way at about 0.24 grams per cubic centimetre, less than a quarter of water, which is why it floats so eagerly. Divide a fixed mass by these densities and the volumes swing wildly. One ton of iron, 1,000 kilograms, fits into about 0.127 cubic metres, roughly 127 litres, a cube less than knee high. The same ton of cork needs about 4.17 cubic metres, a stack that fills a small room corner.

Water: 1.00 g per cubic cm

Iron: about 7.87 g per cubic cm

Cork: about 0.24 g per cubic cm

One ton of iron: about 0.127 cubic metres

One ton of cork: about 4.17 cubic metres

One ton of loose feathers: about 20 cubic metres, at an assumed loose packing of 50 kg per cubic metre

The feather end of the scale

Feathers are not a standard material with one fixed density, because most of a feather pile is trapped air. State the assumption plainly and the maths is honest: if loose feathers are packed so lightly that a cubic metre of the pile weighs about 50 kilograms, then a ton of them fills 20 cubic metres. That is a small truck, filled to the roof, carrying exactly the same weight as an iron cube you could almost wrap your arms around. Same mass, wildly different volume, and density is the whole explanation.

Why steel ships float

Density also settles the old puzzle of the steel ship. A solid block of steel sinks, since steel is nearly eight times denser than water. A ship floats because the hull is mostly hollow: the steel skin plus the air inside it average out to less than the density of water. What matters is the average density of the whole object, ship, cargo and air together, against the water it pushes aside. Load a ship until its average density passes that of water and it goes down, which is why load lines are painted on hulls. To test densities, masses and volumes of your own, our Density Calculator works the formula in any direction.

Sources: Royal Society of Chemistry periodic table density data and the ChartsLoom density chart; volumes computed exactly from volume = mass divided by density. The feather figure uses the packing assumption stated in the keybox.