Everyday

Percentage Off: Why 50% Plus 20% Is Not 70%

Percentage Off: Why 50% Plus 20% Is Not 70%

Sale signs love stacking numbers. A rail promises 50 percent off, and a second sign on top offers an extra 20 percent off at the till. Most shoppers do the obvious sum in their heads: 50 plus 20 makes 70 percent off. It feels right, and it is wrong. On a $100 item, the till will not ask you for $30. It will ask for $40. The missing ten dollars are not a scam or a till error. They are the natural result of how percentages work, and once you see the mechanism, you will never read a stacked offer the same way again.

Each discount shrinks the base for the next one

A percentage is always a share of something, and in a stacked sale the something keeps changing. Start with the $100 item. The first discount, 50 percent off, removes $50 and leaves a price of $50. Now the extra 20 percent arrives, but it does not reach back to the original $100. It applies to the price as it stands, which is $50. Twenty percent of $50 is $10, so the till removes $10 more and settles at $40. You saved $60 in total, which is a real discount of 60 percent, not 70. A true 70 percent off would have taken the price to $30.

The quick way to check any stacked offer

There is a shortcut that never fails. Instead of adding the discounts, multiply what is left after each one. A 50 percent discount leaves 50 percent of the price standing, and a 20 percent discount leaves 80 percent standing. Multiply 0.5 by 0.8 and you get 0.4, meaning 40 percent of the original price survives, so the real discount is 60 percent. The order makes no difference: 20 percent first and then 50 percent lands on the same $40, because multiplication does not care which way round it runs.

Starting price: $100

After 50 percent off: $50

Extra 20 percent off $50: saves $10 more

Final price: $40

Total saved: $60, a real discount of 60 percent

A true 70 percent off price would be: $30

How to shop with clear eyes

None of this makes stacked sales bad deals. Sixty percent off is still a strong saving, and shops advertise the stack because two lively numbers beat one honest one. The skill is simply to price the offer yourself before the sign prices it for you. When a deal stacks percentages, run the leftover multiplication, or check the final figure in seconds with our Discount Calculator. Judge every offer by the price you actually pay, never by the numbers added together on the poster.

Sources: GoCalc, Discount Calculator guide to successive discounts; ToolCalcs, How to Calculate a Discount. All figures in this story were computed exactly from the prices stated in the text.