Health

Ideal Weight: Where the Ranges Come From

Ideal Weight: Where the Ranges Come From

Ideal weight sounds like a single magic number waiting at your height. In reality it is a family of formulas, and the most famous one was never designed to judge how anyone looks. It was built in 1974 to help doctors dose a medicine, and it survives today because it is simple, not because it was ever proven to mark the healthiest weight for a person.

A formula built for medicine, not mirrors

The Devine formula was published by pharmacist B. J. Devine in 1974, in a note about dosing the antibiotic gentamicin. Some drugs are dosed by body weight, and doctors needed a standard weight for a given height that ignored fat, because the drug spreads through lean tissue. Devine gave them a straight line: for men, start at 50 kilograms for a height of 5 feet and add 2.3 kilograms for every inch above that. For women, start at 45.5 kilograms and add the same 2.3 kilograms per inch.

The formula caught on far beyond its original job. Hospitals still use it for drug dosing, and the predicted body weight used to set ventilators in intensive care is essentially the same equation. But nothing in its history involved measuring which weight made people live longest or feel best. It is a dosing convention that escaped the pharmacy.

Two worked examples, checked two ways

Take a man who is 5 feet 10 inches tall. He is 10 inches over 5 feet, so Devine gives 50 plus 10 times 2.3, which is 73.0 kilograms, about 161 pounds. A woman of 5 feet 5 inches is 5 inches over, so she gets 45.5 plus 5 times 2.3, which is 57.0 kilograms, about 126 pounds.

Now cross-check those single numbers against the healthy BMI range, the weight band that matches a body mass index of 18.5 to 24.9 in the World Health Organization classification. At 5 feet 10 inches, that band runs from about 58.5 to 78.7 kilograms, and the Devine figure of 73 sits inside it, at a BMI of about 23.1. At 5 feet 5 inches, the band runs from about 50.4 to 67.9 kilograms, and the Devine figure of 57 sits inside it too, at a BMI of about 20.9. The formula lands in the healthy zone, but the zone is more than 20 kilograms wide, and the formula picks one point in it.

Why a range beats a single number

Devine and its cousins, the Robinson, Miller and Hamwi formulas, all use height and sex and nothing else. They cannot see muscle, bone frame, age or fitness, and they disagree with each other by several kilograms at the same height. A muscular athlete will sit above every one of them while carrying little fat. Treat the single figure as a reference point, the wide BMI band as the context, and your own health markers as the deciding evidence.

Devine formula, men: 50 kg plus 2.3 kg for each inch over 5 feet

Devine formula, women: 45.5 kg plus 2.3 kg for each inch over 5 feet

Man, 5 feet 10 inches: 73.0 kg by Devine, healthy BMI range 58.5 to 78.7 kg

Woman, 5 feet 5 inches: 57.0 kg by Devine, healthy BMI range 50.4 to 67.9 kg

See the figure for your own height, alongside the other classic formulas, with our Ideal Weight Calculator.

Sources: Devine, Drug Intelligence and Clinical Pharmacy (1974); World Health Organization BMI classification for adults. This story is general information, not medical advice.