Money

How Much Do You Need to Retire? The 25 Times Rule, Checked

How Much Do You Need to Retire? The 25 Times Rule, Checked

Ask a room of savers how much money they need to retire and most will shrug. One famous shortcut gives them a number in seconds: save 25 times what you spend in a year. It sounds almost too simple, so we checked where it comes from, what the maths really says, and where the rule stops being true.

The rule, and why 25 and 4 percent are the same number

Start with spending, not income. Say your life costs 40,000 dollars a year. Twenty five times that is 1,000,000 dollars, and that is the target the rule sets. The 25 is not magic. It is the mirror image of the 4 percent rule, which says a retiree can take out 4 percent of the starting pot in the first year of retirement, then raise that same dollar amount with inflation each year after. Four percent of 1,000,000 dollars is 40,000 dollars, exactly one year of spending. And 1 divided by 0.04 is 25, which is why the two rules always travel together: multiply your spending by 25 to build the pot, then withdraw 4 percent of the pot to fund the spending.

Yearly spending in the example: $40,000

The 25 times target: $1,000,000

First year withdrawal at 4 percent: $40,000

Where the 25 comes from: 1 / 0.04 = 25

Retirement length the studies tested: about 30 years

Where the 4 percent came from

In 1994, a financial planner named William Bengen published a study in the Journal of Financial Planning. He tested withdrawal rates against United States market history going back to 1926, asking which starting rate, lifted by inflation each year, would have survived every 30 year retirement in the record. His answer was about 4 percent. Four years later, in 1998, three professors at Trinity University, Philip Cooley, Carl Hubbard and Daniel Walz, ran a wider version of the same test across different mixes of stocks and bonds. Their work, known as the Trinity study, pointed to a similar answer for portfolios holding plenty of stocks. Notice the exact shape of the rule: 4 percent of the starting balance in year one, then that dollar amount adjusted for inflation. It is not 4 percent of whatever the pot happens to be worth each year.

A rule of thumb, with the assumptions showing

Both studies looked backwards at one country's unusually strong stretch of market history, and neither promised the future would repeat it. The rule quietly assumes a retirement of about 30 years, so anyone retiring at 45 needs the money to last much longer. It leaves out taxes and investment fees. It also hides a risk that averages smooth over: a market crash in the first few years of withdrawals does far more damage than the same crash later on. So treat 25 times spending as a rule of thumb with assumptions, not a guarantee. It is a first target that gets you moving, to be adjusted for your own country, health, housing and plans.

To find your own number, multiply your yearly spending by 25, then plan the road there with our Savings Goal Calculator, and watch what steady growth adds along the way in the Compound Interest Calculator.

Sources: William Bengen in the Journal of Financial Planning (1994) and the Trinity study by Cooley, Hubbard and Walz (1998), as reported by Compound Ladder and Talk Through Wealth; the spending figures computed exactly for this story. This story is general information, not financial advice.