Tipping: How Much, Where, and the Maths at the Table
The meal was lovely, the service was kind, and then the bill arrives and the table goes quiet while everyone suddenly pretends to study the dessert menu. Tipping turns a pleasant evening into a maths test with an audience. The good news is that the rules in the United States are simpler than the anxiety suggests: one clear percentage range, one quiet custom about tax, and a ten-second trick that reaches the answer without a calculator.
The standard range
For sit-down service in the United States, etiquette authorities such as the Emily Post Institute put the tip at 15 to 20 percent of the bill, with 18 to 20 percent the common choice for good service and 15 percent the floor for service that was merely adequate. The range carries weight because servers in many states are paid a lower base wage on the assumption that tips make up the difference, so at a table-service restaurant the tip is treated as part of the price of the meal rather than an optional bonus. On an $86 check the maths is gentle: 15 percent is $12.90, 18 percent is $15.48 and 20 percent is $17.20, taking the evening to $98.90, $101.48 or $103.20 in total. Counter service and coffee shops play by softer rules, where a dollar or two is a courtesy rather than an obligation, and customs in many other countries differ entirely.
Tip before tax, not after
The quiet custom is that the percentage applies to the bill before tax, because the tax was never part of the service. It is money collected for the government that simply happens to share your receipt. Watch what it does to the numbers: on the $86 dinner, 8 percent tax adds $6.88 and the receipt total reads $92.88. Twenty percent of the pre-tax $86 is $17.20, while 20 percent of the taxed total comes to $18.58. The $1.38 difference will not ruin anyone, and plenty of generous diners tip on the total on purpose, but the textbook answer uses the pre-tax subtotal, which is printed on every receipt one line above the tax. Tip on the total if you like; just know that you are tipping on the tax as well.
Standard for US sit-down service: 15 to 20 percent
Tip on an $86 pre-tax bill at 15 percent: $12.90
At 18 percent: $15.48
At 20 percent: $17.20
Twenty percent before tax vs after 8 percent tax: $17.20 vs $18.58
The ten-second method
The fastest honest method starts with 10 percent, which is just the decimal point moved one place to the left: $8.60 on our $86 bill. Double it and you have 20 percent, $17.20. Halve the 10 percent figure to get $4.30, add it back to the $8.60, and you have 15 percent, $12.90. For 18 percent, take the 20 percent figure and shave a tenth off it. Three small moves cover the whole range, and they work on any bill at any table because percentages scale. If the group is splitting the check, agree on the percentage before anyone opens a banking app, and let one person say the final sum out loud so the whole table hears the same number.
A tip is a judgement about service expressed as arithmetic, so the kindest approach is to choose the percentage calmly and compute it cleanly. When the bill is large, or the table is splitting, our Tip Calculator handles the percentages, the tax question and the per-person shares in one pass.
Sources: the Emily Post Institute general tipping guide and Bottom Line Inc., on US restaurant tipping ranges and the custom of tipping on the pre-tax bill. All dollar figures were computed exactly. The $86 bill and the 8 percent tax rate are examples checked on November 15, 2026; real prices and tax rates vary by place and may change.