Health

Calories In, Calories Out: What a Calorie Calculator Can and Cannot Do

Calories In, Calories Out: What a Calorie Calculator Can and Cannot Do

Calories in, calories out sounds like simple bookkeeping, and at the level of physics it is. Consistently eat more energy than you use and the spare is stored, mostly as fat. Eat less than you use and the body draws on those stores. The hard part is not the idea. It is knowing your real numbers, because both sides of the ledger are estimates.

What the calculator actually works out

A calorie calculator never measures you. It predicts. First it estimates your basal metabolic rate, or BMR, the energy your body burns at complete rest just staying alive: breathing, pumping blood, building cells. Most calculators use the Mifflin-St Jeor equation, published in 1990. For men, it takes ten times your weight in kilograms, adds 6.25 times your height in centimetres, takes away five times your age, and adds five. For women, the same sum ends by taking away 161 instead.

Then comes the second step. The BMR is multiplied by an activity factor, from 1.2 for a sedentary, desk based life up to 1.9 for very hard physical work or training. The result is an estimate of your total daily energy expenditure, roughly the calories you need to stay the same weight.

Take a woman of 30 who weighs 65 kilograms and is 165 centimetres tall. Her BMR comes out at about 1,370 calories a day, and her maintenance needs change a lot with the life she actually lives.

Example BMR: about 1,370 calories a day

Sedentary, times 1.2: about 1,644 calories a day

Lightly active, times 1.375: about 1,884 calories a day

Moderately active, times 1.55: about 2,124 calories a day

Very active, times 1.725: about 2,364 calories a day

Extra active, times 1.9: about 2,603 calories a day

Why your real number moves

The equation has been tested against measured metabolism in research reviews, and for most healthy adults it lands within about 10 percent of the measured figure. That is good for a formula, but it still leaves a wide personal margin. Muscle burns more energy at rest than fat, so two people of identical weight can burn quite differently. Movement outside formal exercise, the walking, standing and fidgeting of an ordinary day, varies hugely between people and is barely captured by picking one activity band. Age, hormones, illness, some medicines and a long stretch of dieting can each nudge the real figure up or down.

The food side is no firmer. Labels are rounded, portions are guessed, and a splash of cooking oil can hide in a meal uncounted. None of this makes the calculator useless. It makes it a starting line rather than a verdict.

The sensible way to use it is as a test. Eat near the estimate for two or three weeks, watch the trend of your weight rather than any single day, and adjust in small steps. Begin with your own estimate in our Calorie Calculator.

Sources: Mifflin, St Jeor and colleagues, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition (1990), and Frankenfield and colleagues, review in the Journal of the American Dietetic Association (2005). This story is general information, not medical advice.