Rent or Buy? The Five-Year Test
Almost everyone who weighs renting against buying starts with the monthly payment, but the payment is not where the decision is won or lost. Buying carries heavy one-off costs at both ends, the fees when you purchase and the commission when you sell, and those costs need years of living in the home to spread out. That is why a five-year horizon is such a useful test, and why one simple ratio is the fastest first check before you run any detailed numbers.
One ratio that sorts most markets
The price-to-rent ratio takes the price of a home and divides it by a full year of rent for a similar home nearby. The reading is widely used by housing writers and economists. A ratio under 15 means the price is low compared with rents, so buying usually comes out ahead. Between 15 and 20 the answer is genuinely too close to call, and personal factors decide it. Over 20, rents are cheap compared with prices, so renting usually wins on cost alone. Treat the bands as a filter, not a verdict, because the ratio ignores mortgage rates, taxes and repairs.
Example home price: $350,000
Rent for a similar home: $1,800 a month, $21,600 a year
Price-to-rent ratio: 16.2
Under 15: buying usually wins
15 to 20: too close to call
Over 20: renting usually wins
Running the example
Take a home priced at $350,000 in a neighbourhood where a similar place rents for $1,800 a month. A year of rent is $21,600, and $350,000 divided by $21,600 gives a ratio of 16.2. That sits in the gray zone, but near its lower edge, so buying is at least a serious candidate. The five-year part of the test matters here: buying and selling costs together can approach a tenth of the price once purchase fees, moving costs and selling commission are counted. Stay only two or three years and those costs can erase any advantage. Stay five years or more and they are spread thin enough for the sums to have a chance.
What the ratio leaves out
The ratio says nothing about the mortgage rate you can actually get, and a high rate can push a borderline case toward renting. It also assumes you compare like with like, so always set the price against the rent of a home genuinely similar to the one you would buy, ideally on the same street. It also skips the running costs owners pay and renters avoid, such as property tax, insurance and repairs, and it ignores the fact that rents tend to rise while a fixed mortgage payment stays flat. How secure your job is, and how sure you are about the area, matter as much as any figure. Use the ratio to sort your market, then run your own price, rent and timeline through our Rent vs Buy Calculator for the fuller picture.
Sources: price-to-rent bands checked against True Housing Cost and Worth It Calculators. The home price and rent figures are examples checked on November 15, 2026; real prices vary and may change.